The Christian Studies Blog


"Why, O My Soul, Are You sorrowing?" The Story Behind Psalm 43 in Timeless

Posted by Dr. Mark Shipp on December 28, 2017 at 10:38 AM

Lament pic.png

This is the second in the series of stories behind some of the songs from Timeless: Ancient Psalms for the Church Today Psalter/Commentary. It was written by Gary Pendergrass of Greenville, Texas, and is a gripping story of how a lament psalm ministered to him during his son’s near fatal cardiac arrest in the hospital.


I had been assigned Psalm 43. While working on the song, I was struck by the fact that the psalmist’s emotions were all over the map. In one verse, he was in distress by those who were against him, and he felt abandoned by God. Then he sought guidance from God, followed by praise. Then he was back to his distress, asking himself why he felt that way. I was having trouble wrapping my mind around this roller coaster of emotions.

While in the middle of working through this, I experienced the worst day of my life. My son, sixteen years old at the time, suffered a cardiac arrest while in the hospital. It took ten minutes of CPR by the doctor before my son’s heart began beating again. He remained in a coma for the next week, and the doctors weren’t offering us much hope. During that week, I found myself identifying with the psalmist. One minute, I felt the despair of the situation very keenly.  The next, I praised God for the small signs of progress we could see. I prayed for guidance and asked myself why my faith didn’t feel as strong as I believed it should be.

Thankfully, God brought my son back to me. As I finished writing the song, I felt each of the psalmist’s emotions. I have tried to give voice to those emotions in this song: despair and searching, hope and praise. I especially identified with the tenors, who sing, “Why, O my soul, are you sorrowing? Put your hope in the God who, through the night, ever leads you by his holy light.” I believe that, in his providence, God provided a psalm in my hour of need to speak to my soul and lead me to feel his presence in a very difficult situation.  To God be the glory.


Timeless is a commentary set of all new translations and commentaries on the psalms by established Old Testament scholars for the layperson. Timeless also includes 2–3 new musical settings following each psalm to enhance worship and reflection, study and devotion. Timeless books may be purchased through,, or Professionally recorded CDs and booklets of the music may be purchased through and

Topics: Personal, Worship, Psalms, Timeless

Christian Studies
Scholarship for the Church

Sign up to receive blog updates. You'll always have the option to choose the frequency by which we contact you. Email for questions. Happy reading!

Subscribe to Email Updates

Recent Posts

All blog comments will be moderated before posting. Please keep them respectful and on topic with the article's content.
The opinions expressed by individual authors are not necessarily shared by other authors or the position of Austin Graduate School of Theology.